In plain words
One trial found that men taking creatine during heavy weight training gained more lean mass than men on a placebo. A newer trial found lean mass rose after a week of creatine alone, with no added gain during the training that followed. A third found no difference in body water.
The short answer
Three randomized trials measured body composition. Volek and colleagues (1999) found fat-free mass rose 6.3% with creatine against 3.1% with placebo in 19 resistance-trained men over 12 weeks (a 25 g loading week, then less). Desai and colleagues (2025) found a 7-day wash-in raised lean mass, then 5 g a day added nothing over 12 weeks of training; the authors suggest more may be needed, and the ledger has no n. Kreider and colleagues (1998) found no difference in total body water percentage in 25 people on 15.75 g a day for 28 days. Certainty is low: the measures differ, and the training gain came from 19 men.
Where the evidence sits
More lean mass with creatine
No difference
■ measured by the source's own study · ◪ pooled analysis, may overlap studies counted here · □ reported, reviewed or argued, no new data
Who says what
| Source | Finding | Design | People | Dose and length | Funding and independence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Volek JS et al., 1999 | Fat-free mass 6.3% vs 3.1% | Randomized, placebo-controlled | 19 trained men | 25 g/day, 1 week; 5 g/day, 12 weeks | Not in ledger |
| Desai et al., UNSW, 2025 | Early lean mass rise; no added gain in training | Randomized, vs training alone | Not in ledger | 7 days, then 5 g/day, 12 weeks | Not in ledger |
| Kreider RB et al., 1998 | No body water difference | Randomized, placebo-controlled | 25 | 15.75 g/day, 28 days | Not in ledger |
| Liu et al., 2025 | More lean tissue with training | Meta-analysis; a pooled estimate that may include the trials above | Older adults | Up to 32 weeks | Not in ledger |
| The Hill, Liberty Vittert Capito | Doubts first-week gain was muscle | Opinion column on a randomized trial | Not in ledger | Not in ledger | Re-reads a trial |
Fat-free mass 6.3% vs 3.1%
Early lean mass rise; no added gain in training
No body water difference
More lean tissue with training
Doubts first-week gain was muscle
Did creatine add lean mass during weight training?
Volek and colleagues (1999) randomized 19 resistance-trained men to creatine (25 g a day for a week, then 5 g a day) or placebo during 12 weeks of heavy training:
After 12 wk, significant (P < or = 0.05) increases in body mass and fat-free mass were greater in creatine (6.3% and 6.3%, respectively) than placebo (3.6% and 3.1%, respectively) subjects.
Liu and colleagues (2025) found more lean tissue with creatine plus resistance training in older adults, in a pooled estimate that may include the trials above; the ledger has no n for it.
Was the first-week gain muscle?
Desai and colleagues (2025) gave creatine monohydrate (CrM) for 7 days before any training, then 5 g a day through 12 weeks of resistance training, against training alone; the ledger has no n for this trial. The wash-in week raised DXA lean mass, mostly in women. Then:
Thereafter, CrM did not enhance lean body mass growth when combined with resistance training, likely due to its short-term effects on lean body mass measurements.
Split by sex, they found no creatine advantage in lean mass growth for women or men. A column in The Hill by Liberty Vittert Capito appears to describe the same trial, and doubts that the first-week gain was muscle:
But muscle doesn’t materialize in seven days.
Did body water change?
Kreider and colleagues (1998) gave 25 people 15.75 g of creatine a day or placebo for 28 days:
while no differences were observed in the percentage of total body water
The ledger has no lean mass figure from this trial.
Why the sources disagree
The trials measured different things: fat-free mass (Volek), DXA lean mass (Desai) and body water percentage (Kreider). Desai and colleagues report the first creatine week apart from the training weeks; Volek and colleagues report one change after 12 weeks in 19 men on 25 g, then 5 g a day. For the Desai trial (5 g a day, 12 weeks, n not in ledger), the authors propose that more than 5 g a day may be necessary to add lean mass. Liu's older adults form a pooled estimate that may include the trials above. The Hill re-reads a trial it did not conduct, and the ledger has no funding for any source.
What would settle it
A pre-registered, placebo-controlled trial in 200 women and men comparing 5 g with 10 g of creatine a day over 16 weeks of supervised training, measuring DXA lean mass and total body water at baseline, day 7 and week 16. A matching result from a second, independent group would raise certainty to moderate.
How this page was made
The 5 sources are three randomized trials and one meta-analysis from a literature search, a pooled estimate that may include the trials above, plus a column in The Hill that appears to re-read one of the trials. Safety results from creatine trials in ALS, Huntington disease and Parkinson disease were left out as off the question. Every claim was copied word for word from its source into the Longevity Circle ledger and checked against the original text, and a person approved each one. "Contested" means independent trials point in both directions; certainty follows the GRADE levels used in medical reviews. Drafting was assisted by AI.
Changelog: 23 Sep 2026, first version, 5 sources.
