an independent evidence notebook
Who claims what about longevity, and where the sources disagree.
- Grape Seed Extract
Does grape seed extract lower oxidative stress?
Leaning: lower oxidative stress · Low certainty
- Markers improved5 measured + 1 pooled
- No difference1 measured + 1 pooled + 1 reported
6 measured studies · 208 people
Five of seven small randomized trials found grape seed extract lowered blood markers of oxidative stress or raised antioxidants; two found no difference from placebo. Certainty is low.
- Omega-3
Does omega-3 prevent heart attacks and strokes?
Leaning: little or no effect · Moderate certainty
- Fewer events1 pooled
- Little or no difference4 pooled + 1 reported
0 measured studies
Five large pooled analyses of omega-3 trials mostly found little or no effect on cardiovascular events. One linked omega-3 with slightly fewer major events, more so in trials of EPA on its own.
- Grape Seed Extract
Does grape seed extract lower blood pressure?
Contested · Low certainty
- Lower than placebo2 measured + 2 pooled
- No difference from placebo3 measured + 1 reported
5 measured studies · 214 people (+1 with no reported size)
Five small randomized trials of grape seed extract split on blood pressure: two found lower readings than placebo and three found no difference. Pooled estimates that may include these trials disagree about systolic pressure.
- L-Theanine
Does L-theanine improve attention?
Leaning: better attention, taken with caffeine · Low certainty
- Attention improved5 measured + 1 pooled
- No effect1 reported
- Depends on form1 measured
6 measured studies · 104 people (+2 with no reported size)
Small single-dose studies mostly found better attention when L-theanine was taken with caffeine. Results for L-theanine alone are few and mixed, and one review credits the combined effect mainly to caffeine.
- Berberine
Does berberine improve insulin sensitivity?
Leaning: improves · Low certainty
- Insulin sensitivity improved3 measured + 1 pooled
- No clear difference2 measured
5 measured studies · 816 people
Two of four randomized trials found berberine improved insulin sensitivity measures and two found no clear difference from their comparison groups. A before-after study found lower insulin resistance. Certainty is low.
- Creatine
Does creatine increase muscle mass?
Leaning: increase · Low certainty
- More muscle or larger fibers4 measured
- No muscle gain1 reported
4 measured studies · 75 people
Four small studies that measured muscle in people taking creatine found gains in muscle or fiber size over 28 days to 16 weeks. Commentators argue that the early gain on a DEXA scan is partly water and that creatine alone does not build muscle.
- Akkermansia
Does Akkermansia lower body weight?
Leaning: lower · Low certainty
- Lower weight or less regain3 measured
- No difference between groups1 measured
4 measured studies · 214 people (+1 with no reported size)
Three of four small randomized trials of Akkermansia products lean toward lower body weight or less weight regain, one by a margin that missed statistical significance; a fourth found no difference overall. Certainty is low.
- NMN
Is oral NMN absorbed into the blood?
Leaning: higher blood NAD · Moderate certainty
- Higher NAD or breakdown products7 measured + 1 pooled
7 measured studies · 244 people
Five small randomized trials found higher blood NAD or its breakdown products after 14 days to 12 weeks of NMN than with placebo. In the hours after a single dose, two studies saw no rise in blood NMN itself.
- Akkermansia
Does taking akkermansia change the gut microbiome?
Leaning: no overall change · Low certainty
- No overall change2 measured
- Depends on starting level1 measured
3 measured studies
In two of three randomized trials, akkermansia did not change the overall mix of gut bacteria. One of those trials reported that live or pasteurized akkermansia was associated with more of the bacterium in stool. The third trial found it colonized the gut in people who started with little.
- Berberine
Does berberine lower cholesterol and triglycerides?
Leaning: lower · Low certainty
- Lipids fell6 measured + 2 pooled
- No significant change1 pooled
6 measured studies · 475 people
Four small randomized trials of 36 to 184 people over 3 months to 16 weeks found lower cholesterol and triglycerides with berberine than with placebo, metformin or lifestyle change. Certainty is low because the trials are small and short.
- Berberine
Does berberine lower fasting blood sugar?
Leaning: lower · Low certainty
- Fasting glucose fell5 measured + 1 pooled
- No clear difference1 measured
6 measured studies · 775 people (+1 with no reported size)
Three of four randomized trials found lower fasting blood sugar with berberine, and the fourth found no clear difference. Certainty is low because the trials are few and differ in people, dose and comparison.
- L-Theanine
Does L-theanine improve cognitive function?
Leaning: no effect · Low certainty
- Better than placebo2 measured
- No difference from placebo3 measured + 1 pooled + 1 reported
- Worse than placebo1 measured
6 measured studies · 195 people (+2 with no reported size)
Most small trials of L-theanine alone found no difference from placebo on thinking tests. Two found gains, and one found fewer correct answers on a subtraction test. Certainty is low.
- Ashwagandha
Does ashwagandha improve sleep quality?
Leaning: better sleep · Low certainty
- Sleep improved2 measured + 2 pooled + 1 reported
2 measured studies · 230 people
Two placebo-controlled trials, of 150 adults for six weeks and 80 people for eight weeks, both found better sleep with ashwagandha than with placebo. Certainty is low: the trials are short and small, and the ledger has no funding information for either.
- Taurine
Does taurine lower cholesterol and triglycerides?
Contested · Low certainty
- Blood fats fell1 measured + 1 pooled + 1 reported
- No difference1 measured
2 measured studies · 50 people
Two small randomized trials of taurine disagree on blood fats: one found lower triglycerides at 3 g a day, the other no change at 1.5 g a day. A 2024 pooled analysis that may include both found lower cholesterol and triglycerides.
- Stool transplant
Does a stool transplant improve insulin sensitivity?
Leaning: no effect · Low certainty
- Insulin sensitivity improved1 pooled
- No significant change2 measured
2 measured studies · 21 people (+1 with no reported size)
Two small randomized trials of fecal microbiota transplantation found no significant change in insulin sensitivity. A pooled analysis reported that it may help in metabolic syndrome, but that analysis may include the same trials.
- Glutathione
Does oral glutathione lower oxidative stress?
Contested · Low certainty
- Oxidative stress marker fell1 measured
- No change1 measured
2 measured studies · 94 people
Two small randomized trials disagree: 250 or 1,000 mg a day for six months lowered a blood marker of oxidative stress in 54 people, while 500 mg twice a day for four weeks changed no oxidative stress biomarkers in 40 healthy adults.
- Ashwagandha
Does ashwagandha raise testosterone?
Contested · Low certainty
- Rose more than placebo2 measured + 2 reported
- No difference from placebo2 measured
4 measured studies · 196 people (+1 with no reported size)
Four randomized trials split evenly. Two found testosterone rose more with ashwagandha than with placebo in men, and two found no difference against placebo, one of them in women. Certainty is low.
- Rhodiola Rosea
Does rhodiola rosea help with depression?
Contested · Low certainty
- Depression improved vs placebo1 measured
- No difference from placebo2 measured
3 measured studies · 149 people (+1 with no reported size)
Three randomized trials measured rhodiola and depression. One six-week trial found improvement over placebo, and two, lasting 28 days and 12 weeks, found no significant difference from placebo. Certainty is low.
- Rhodiola Rosea
Does rhodiola rosea reduce fatigue?
Leaning: lower fatigue · Very low certainty
- Less fatigue4 measured + 1 reported
- Evidence insufficient1 reported
- Less fatigue only under some stress1 measured
5 measured studies · 377 people (+1 with no reported size)
Three of four small randomized trials found less fatigue with rhodiola extract than with placebo, and a fourth suggested an effect only under certain stressful conditions. A 2012 review that may include these trials judged the evidence insufficient.
- Ashwagandha
Does ashwagandha reduce anxiety?
Leaning: lower · Low certainty
- Anxiety scores fell2 measured + 3 pooled + 1 reported
- Unclear or no effect1 reported
2 measured studies · 40 people (+1 with no reported size)
Two randomized trials found lower anxiety scores with ashwagandha, and pooled analyses that may include them agree, but certainty is low and a US health agency calls the evidence on anxiety unclear.
- Taurine
Does blood taurine fall with age?
Contested · Very low certainty
- Taurine lower in older people1 measured
- No association with age1 measured
2 measured studies · 137 people (+1 with no reported size)
Two observational studies disagree on whether blood taurine falls with age in people. One reported serum taurine more than 80% lower in elderly people, and another found no association with age in 137 men aged 20 to 93. Certainty is very low.
- Whey Protein
Does whey protein increase muscle strength?
Leaning: no difference · Low certainty
- Strength rose more with supplement2 measured + 1 pooled
- No difference from comparison5 measured
7 measured studies · 730 people (+2 with no reported size)
Five of seven randomized trials found no difference in strength or power between people given whey or a whey-containing supplement and a comparison group. Two found a larger grip strength gain. Certainty is low.
- Creatine
Does creatine change body composition?
Contested · Low certainty
- More lean mass with creatine1 measured + 1 pooled
- No difference2 measured
3 measured studies · 44 people (+1 with no reported size)
Three randomized trials split on whether creatine adds lean mass: one found a larger fat-free mass gain during weight training, one found an early rise but no added gain over the training weeks, and one found no body water difference.
- Whey Protein
Does whey protein increase muscle mass?
Leaning: small gain in muscle · Low certainty
- More muscle than control5 measured + 1 pooled
- No difference3 measured
8 measured studies · 793 people (+2 with no reported size)
Five of eight randomized trials found small gains in muscle with whey supplements, mostly in sarcopenic, dieting or training adults; three found no difference, two of them in healthy older adults. Certainty is low.
- Rhodiola Rosea
Does rhodiola rosea lower inflammation?
Contested · Very low certainty
- CRP lower with rhodiola1 measured
- No difference from placebo2 measured
3 measured studies · 62 people (+1 with no reported size)
One exercise trial, described in a 2012 review, found lower CRP after rhodiola. A marathon trial and a smaller four-week study found no difference from placebo in inflammation markers. The studies are few and small.
- Taurine
Does taurine improve insulin sensitivity?
Contested · Very low certainty
- Insulin markers improved1 measured + 1 pooled + 1 reported
- No effect found1 measured
2 measured studies · 36 people
Two small randomized trials of taurine point different ways over 8 weeks: one found no change in insulin sensitivity in 20 men, and one was associated with higher adiponectin in 16 obese women. A pooled analysis that may include them found lower fasting insulin.
- NMN
Does NMN change liver function?
Leaning: no effect · Low certainty
- Lower liver enzymes1 pooled
- No change in liver tests3 measured + 2 pooled
3 measured studies · 65 people (+1 with no reported size)
Three small randomized trials of NMN found no change in liver blood tests. Pooled analyses that may include those trials split on the liver enzyme ALT: two found no difference and one found lower levels.
- NMN
Does NMN improve sleep quality?
Contested · Low certainty
- Sleep scores improved1 measured
- No difference found2 measured
3 measured studies · 178 people
Two 12-week randomized trials of NMN at 250 mg a day disagree on sleep quality: one found better scores than placebo, the other found no significant difference. A small single-dose study found no change.
- NMN
Does NMN improve muscle strength?
Leaning: no difference · Low certainty
- Strength improved1 measured
- No difference3 measured + 1 pooled + 3 reported
4 measured studies · 170 people (+1 with no reported size)
Two of three randomized trials and a 24-week placebo comparison found no gain in strength with NMN; one trial in healthy older men found partly better grip. Certainty is low because the studies are small and short.
- NMN
Does NMN improve insulin sensitivity?
Contested · Low certainty
- Insulin sensitivity improved1 measured + 1 pooled
- No difference from placebo1 measured + 2 pooled
2 measured studies · 78 people (+1 with no reported size)
Two small randomized trials of NMN disagree on insulin sensitivity. One in women with prediabetes found a rise, and one in adults found no difference from placebo. Three pooled analyses, which may include those trials, also disagree.
- Sauna
Does sauna lower blood pressure?
Leaning · Low certainty
- Blood pressure lower3 measured
- No difference1 measured
- Mixed results within the study1 measured
- Less hypertension with frequent sauna1 measured
6 measured studies · 1,839 people
Three of the four small randomized trials here found lower systolic blood pressure with sauna, and one eight-week trial of sauna alone found no difference. Certainty is low.
- Glutathione
Is oral glutathione absorbed?
Contested · Low certainty
- No rise in blood levels2 measured + 1 pooled + 1 reported
- Rise in blood levels1 measured + 1 reported
3 measured studies · 101 people
Small studies split on whether swallowed glutathione reaches the blood. The results appear to track how long people took it and what each study compared against.