In plain words

Most of the randomized trials here found that adults given a whey supplement, often with exercise or added vitamins, ended up with slightly more muscle than those given a placebo or control. Three others, two of them in healthy older adults, found no difference.

The short answer

Of eight trials, five found a small muscle gain with whey: Bauer (2015, 380 people, twice daily, 13 weeks), Bo (2018, 60, 6 months), Rondanelli (2016, 130, 22 g whey, 12 weeks), Verreijen (2014, 80, 21 g protein, 13 weeks) and Volek (2013, 63, about 9 months); the ledger has no dose for Bo or Volek. Three found no difference: Chalé (2012, 80, 40 g a day, 6 months), Ceglia (2026, 24 weeks) and Holm (2019, one year), the last two with no n or dose in the ledger. Certainty is low because the gains were small and most positive trials added nutrients or exercise.

Where the evidence sits

More muscle than control

■ Randomized trial, Bauer et al., 2015 · 380 people · 13 weeks
■ Randomized trial, Bo et al., 2018 · 60 people · 6 months
■ Randomized trial, Rondanelli et al., 2016 · 130 people · 12 wk
■ Randomized trial, Verreijen et al., 2014 · 80 people · 13 wk
■ Randomized trial, Volek et al., 2013 · 63 people · ~9 months
◪ Pooled analysis, Nutrients 2023 systematic review and meta-analysis: whey protein during resistance training in older people with sarcopenia, 2023 · may overlap studies counted here

No difference

■ Randomized trial, Chalé et al., 2012 · 80 people · 6 months
■ Randomized trial, Ceglia et al., 2026 · ledger has no n
■ Randomized trial, Holm et al., 2019 · ledger has no n

■ measured by the source's own study · ◪ pooled analysis, may overlap studies counted here · □ reported, reviewed or argued, no new data

Evidence weight8686 / 100?

Who says what

SourceFindingDesignPeopleDose and lengthFunding and independence
Bauer, 2015+0.17 kgRandomized38013 weeksNot in ledger
Bo, 2018+0.18 kg/m2Randomized606 monthsNot in ledger
Rondanelli, 2016+1.7 kgRandomized13022 g, 12 weeksNot in ledger
Verreijen, 2014Limb muscle keptRandomized8021 g, 13 weeksNot in ledger
Volek, 20133.3 vs 2.3 kgRandomized63About 9 monthsNot in ledger
Chalé, 2012No differenceRandomized8040 g, 6 monthsNot in ledger
Ceglia, 2026No differenceRandomizedNot in ledger24 weeksNot in ledger
Holm, 2019No impactRandomizedNot in ledgerA yearNot in ledger
Nutrients meta-analysis, 2023Small gainPooled, may include trials aboveSarcopenicNot in ledgerNot in ledger
Bauer, 2015

+0.17 kg

Design
Randomized
People
380
Dose and length
13 weeks
Funding
Not in ledger
Bo, 2018

+0.18 kg/m2

Design
Randomized
People
60
Dose and length
6 months
Funding
Not in ledger
Rondanelli, 2016

+1.7 kg

Design
Randomized
People
130
Dose and length
22 g, 12 weeks
Funding
Not in ledger
Verreijen, 2014

Limb muscle kept

Design
Randomized
People
80
Dose and length
21 g, 13 weeks
Funding
Not in ledger
Volek, 2013

3.3 vs 2.3 kg

Design
Randomized
People
63
Dose and length
About 9 months
Funding
Not in ledger
Chalé, 2012

No difference

Design
Randomized
People
80
Dose and length
40 g, 6 months
Funding
Not in ledger
Ceglia, 2026

No difference

Design
Randomized
People
Not in ledger
Dose and length
24 weeks
Funding
Not in ledger
Holm, 2019

No impact

Design
Randomized
People
Not in ledger
Dose and length
A year
Funding
Not in ledger

How much muscle did the positive trials add?

Bauer and colleagues (2015) gave 380 people a supplement or control twice daily for 13 weeks and measured appendicular (arm and leg) muscle:

The active group gained more appendicular muscle mass than the control group, between-group effect: 0.17 kg (0.004-0.338), P = .045.

Verreijen and colleagues (2014) gave 80 obese older adults on a 13-week diet and training program 21 g of protein 10 times a week or a control; arm and leg muscle rose 0.4 kg with it and fell 0.5 kg without. Volek and colleagues (2013) found 3.3 kg of lean mass gained with daily whey against 2.3 kg with carbohydrate in 63 untrained adults over about 9 months of training; the ledger has no dose.

Which trials found no difference?

Chalé and colleagues (2012) gave 80 mobility-limited adults aged 70 to 85 whey at 40 g a day or an isocaloric control during 6 months of resistance training; lean mass rose 1.3% against 0.6%:

However, there were no statistically significant differences in the change in any of these variables between groups.

Ceglia and colleagues (2026) found no difference in muscle mass against placebo after 24 weeks in healthy adults aged 65 and over; the ledger has no n or dose. Holm and colleagues (2019) report no impact on muscle mass after a year of whey or collagen in healthy older adults living at home; the ledger has no n.

What does the pooled review add?

A 2023 Nutrients meta-analysis of whey with resistance training in sarcopenic older people found a small pooled effect on arm and leg muscle index; it is a pooled estimate that may include the trials above, not an extra measurement.

Why the sources disagree

The positive results came mostly from sarcopenic older adults (Bo, Rondanelli), dieting obese older adults (Verreijen) and untrained adults starting training (Volek); two null results came from healthy older adults (Ceglia, Holm). Bo's and Verreijen's supplements added vitamins, and Holm's had a collagen arm. Comparisons ranged from placebo to carbohydrate. Chalé's trial included training and found no difference.

What would settle it

A pre-registered, independently funded trial in 400 older adults, split by sarcopenia status, giving 30 g a day of plain whey or an isocaloric placebo for 12 months alongside the same training program, with arm and leg muscle measured by the same scan at 3, 6 and 12 months. A matching result from a second research group would raise certainty to moderate.

How this page was made

The 9 sources are eight trial reports and a 2023 meta-analysis, a pooled estimate that may include the trials above, found by a literature search. Single-dose studies of muscle protein synthesis were left out. Every claim was copied word for word into the Longevity Circle ledger and checked against the original text, and a person approved each one. Certainty follows GRADE levels. Drafting was assisted by AI.

Changelog: 23 Sep 2026, first version, 9 sources.