In plain words
In five of seven trials, most of them in older adults, people given whey or a supplement containing it did not gain more strength or power than people in the comparison group. Two of the seven trials found a larger gain in grip strength with the supplement.
The short answer
Five of seven randomized trials found no difference from the comparison group: Bauer (2015; 380 people, twice daily, 13 weeks), Verreijen (2014; 80 people, 21 g protein, 13 weeks), Chalé (2012; 80 people, 40 g a day, 6 months), Holm (2019; one year, no n or dose in the ledger) and Ceglia (2026; leg press power, 1.5 g/kg a day, 24 weeks, no n in the ledger). Two found a larger grip strength gain: Bo (2018; 60 people, 6 months, no dose in the ledger) and Rondanelli (2016; 130 people, 22 g whey with physical activity, 12 weeks). Certainty is low, because supplements, doses and comparison groups differed.
Where the evidence sits
Strength rose more with supplement
No difference from comparison
■ measured by the source's own study · ◪ pooled analysis, may overlap studies counted here · □ reported, reviewed or argued, no new data
Who says what
| Source | Finding | Design | People | Dose and length | Funding and independence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bauer et al., 2015 | No difference in grip | Randomized, iso-caloric control | 380 sarcopenic older adults | Twice daily, 13 weeks | Not in ledger |
| Verreijen et al., 2014 | No difference in strength | Randomized, isocaloric control | 80 | 21 g protein, 13 weeks | Not in ledger |
| Chalé et al., 2012 | No difference in strength | Randomized, control group | 80 | 40 g a day, 6 months | Not in ledger |
| Holm et al., 2019 | No effect on strength | Randomized, whey or collagen | Healthy older adults | One year | Not in ledger |
| Ceglia et al., 2026 | No difference in leg press power | Randomized, placebo | Adults 65 and over | 1.5 g/kg a day, 24 weeks | Not in ledger |
| Bo et al., 2018 | Grip 2.68 kg higher than placebo | Randomized, combined supplement | 60 | 6 months | Not in ledger |
| Rondanelli et al., 2016 | Grip rose more | Randomized, plus physical activity | 130 sarcopenic elderly | 22 g whey, 12 weeks | Not in ledger |
| Nutrients review, 2023 | Pooled grip gain of 2.31 kg | Meta-analysis, may include trials above | Sarcopenic older people | With resistance training | Not in ledger |
No difference in grip
No difference in strength
No difference in strength
No effect on strength
No difference in leg press power
Grip 2.68 kg higher than placebo
Grip rose more
Pooled grip gain of 2.31 kg
Did strength rise more with whey than without?
Chalé and colleagues (2012) gave 80 people 40 g of whey protein concentrate a day or a control for 6 months, and both groups got stronger:
muscle strength increased 16%-50% in WPC and control groups
Bauer and colleagues (2015) found the same pattern for grip strength in 380 sarcopenic older adults taking a supplement twice daily for 13 weeks, against an iso-caloric control. Rondanelli and colleagues (2016) gave 130 sarcopenic elderly people 22 g of whey with physical activity for 12 weeks and reported a larger grip strength gain than physical activity with placebo.
What does the pooled estimate add?
A 2023 review in Nutrients pooled trials of whey added to resistance training in older people with sarcopenia, a pooled estimate that may include the trials above. The ledger has no n, dose or duration for it, and the review placed the gain below the minimally important clinical difference:
The overall pooled mean difference (MD) estimate showed a significant difference of +2.31 kg
Why the sources disagree
The comparisons differ. Bauer and Verreijen used iso-caloric control groups, Bo and Ceglia used placebo, and Rondanelli compared against physical activity with placebo. The products differ: Bo tested a combined supplement, Holm whey or collagen. The measures differ: three of the seven trials report grip strength, Ceglia leg press power. The 2023 review, which may include the trials here, pooled studies that added whey to resistance training; the ledger has no training details for most of the null trials. Lengths ran from 12 weeks to a year.
What would settle it
A pre-registered trial randomizing at least 400 older adults to whey or an iso-caloric carbohydrate drink for 12 months, with and without supervised resistance training, reporting grip and leg strength against control, then repeated by a second research group.
How this page was made
The 8 sources are seven randomized trials and one meta-analysis that may include some of them, found by a literature search and selected for strength in people. A fitness trainer's article, a claim on allergy and a review's summary of one included trial were left out. Every claim was copied word for word from its source into the Longevity Circle ledger and checked against the original text, and a person approved each one. "Leaning" means most independent measurements point one way; certainty follows the GRADE levels used in medical reviews. Drafting was assisted by AI.
Changelog: 23 Sep 2026, first version, 8 sources.
